A friend asked,
Is Arminianism heretical? If your answer is “yes”, are they to be treated as brethren?
A reply: I agree with John Piper who said in his Calvinism series that as a Calvinist I agree with and believe everything an Arminian believes, I just believe more. This circumvents the either-or fallacy – we both believe the same things, up to a point. The Arminian stops with the enigma of man’s freedom, the Calvinist stops with the enigma of God’s.